AI and Democracy are becoming major global issues as artificial intelligence changes jobs, businesses and everyday life. A BBC News programme titled Is AI a Threat to Democracy? explores whether people have enough power to influence how new technology is introduced. The programme features hosts Asma Khalid, reporting from Washington, D.C., and Tristan Redman. They interview technology journalist and author Brian Merchant, who wrote Blood in the Machine: The Origins of the Rebellion Against Big Tech. The discussion connects today's AI concerns with the Luddite movement in 19th-century England. Today, the word "Luddite" is often used to describe someone who fears technology or cannot use modern devices. However, the original Luddites were not against technology itself. They used machines but fought to protect their jobs, fair wages and dignity. During the late 18th and early 19th centuries, cloth workers were among Britain's largest professional groups. Many worked from home or in small workshops with their families. This system was known as the domestic system, which helped create the term "cottage industry". Workers operated looms, made quality clothes and sold their products to merchants or at local markets. Although they were not wealthy, they had control over their working hours. They could sing, take breaks, walk outside and look after their gardens while working.
The Industrial Revolution gradually changed this traditional way of life. From the second half of the 18th century, factory owners began bringing many machines together inside large buildings to produce goods faster. One important machine was called the wide frame. It could quickly produce two pieces of cloth that were later stitched together. These machines helped factories make products such as stockings, but the goods were often of lower quality than traditional handmade products. Factory owners no longer needed highly trained workers to operate every machine. Instead, they often employed children because they could pay them lower wages. This reduced the income, skills and professional value of experienced workers. Before using violence, cloth workers spent around 10 years peacefully campaigning for their rights. They repeatedly sent petitions to the British Parliament, explaining that machines were replacing jobs, reducing wages and lowering product quality. They also warned that workers could no longer earn enough to feed their families. However, their complaints were repeatedly ignored and even laughed at by members of Parliament. By 1811, falling wages, weak trade, the economic costs of Britain's war against Napoleon and rising war taxes had pushed many workers into extreme poverty. Historians describe the situation as so serious that England was close to civil war.
In 1811, angry workers from towns near Nottingham organised themselves and attacked a local factory owned by a businessman they considered especially unfair. The workers used the term "obnoxious" for factory owners who reduced wages, employed children and ignored traditional trade standards. During the attack, they destroyed the machines responsible for replacing workers rather than destroying everything inside the factory. Their actions temporarily forced some factory owners in the region to agree to restore traditional wages. However, owners who continued using machines gained more market share. Other factory owners soon returned to wage cuts to compete. After a quiet summer, organised labour activists began using the name of a fictional folk hero called Ned Ludd. Like Robin Hood, Ned Ludd became a symbol of justice for ordinary people. The workers sent warning letters to factory owners, explaining their complaints and demanding the removal of machines. One example mentioned how 400 wide frames were replacing the jobs of 800 workers. They warned that Ned Ludd would visit if their demands were ignored. If owners agreed, the workers kept their promises and did not attack. If they refused, organised groups, often led by former military veterans, entered factories at night. They sometimes held supervisors at gunpoint while destroying only the machines they believed were taking jobs. They also warned that entire buildings could be destroyed if the machines returned. The movement became extremely popular across England. Songs about the Luddites were performed in pubs, restaurants and beer halls, and their popularity in local folklore even surpassed that of Robin Hood.
One of the best-known Luddite leaders was George Mellor, a skilled and charismatic cloth finisher from West Riding in Yorkshire. He saw how factory machines were making years of training worthless while families in his community struggled to survive. He organised several successful strikes in the region. His group later targeted Rawfolds Mill, one of the largest factories, owned by William Cartwright, a strong opponent of the Luddites who focused on increasing profits. More than 100 armed Luddites attacked the mill at night. However, Cartwright had prepared for an attack by strengthening the building and hiring armed guards. The attackers could not break through the doors. Several workers were killed in the violent battle, making it the movement's first major defeat. The surviving members scattered. Facing a large military response from the British government, Mellor later became involved in a plan to assassinate another factory owner. One of his fellow Luddites betrayed him and informed the authorities. The government arrested workers across the region and organised public mass executions to frighten the wider working population. Mellor, his fellow conspirators and dozens of other Luddites were executed, many for their involvement in machinery destruction. Others were sentenced to transportation and sent to Australia. Merchant explains that many Australians still take pride in having Luddite ancestors. Australian politicians have also sometimes praised the movement as an example of people fighting for workers' rights.
More than 200 years later, similar concerns are growing around artificial intelligence. US opinion polls show widespread public concern about AI's effects on jobs and society. Many people use AI tools themselves but worry that powerful companies are introducing the technology without asking the public or giving communities a meaningful role in decisions. Merchant compares modern protests against AI data centres with the historical Luddite movement. Residents are attending crowded town hall meetings and city council sessions to oppose new data centre projects and demand temporary bans, known as moratoriums. The programme also discusses two violent incidents. A Molotov cocktail was thrown at the home of OpenAI chief executive Sam Altman. In another incident in Indiana, shots were fired at the front doors of a city council member's home after the council approved a data centre despite strong opposition from residents at a crowded public meeting. These incidents show how anger over technology and local decision-making can become serious public tensions. However, peaceful protest and violence are not the same. The programme also highlights growing anxiety among educated workers. Unlike earlier automation, which heavily affected manual workers such as automobile factory employees around 70 years ago, AI is now reaching white-collar and creative professions. Host Asma Khalid refers to Microsoft research identifying writers, historians, journalists and coders among the professions whose work is highly exposed to AI. Plumbers and electricians appear relatively less exposed for now because their work requires physical skills. Young university graduates are increasingly worried about finding jobs. Software engineers and programmers, once among the highest-paid professionals 10 to 20 years ago, are also facing uncertainty as major companies such as Amazon, Meta and Google expand their focus on AI. Thousands of technology workers have faced layoffs. The pressure on white-collar jobs, combined with the weakening position of the upper-middle class and the declining economic security of millennials, is also changing politics. Merchant says opposition to the power of technology billionaires has become an important political message among newly elected Senate candidates in states including Iowa, Texas and Ohio.
The final part of the discussion examines what happened after the Luddite movement was defeated. Merchant argues that the Luddites did not lose because their ideas failed in public debate. Instead, overwhelming government violence destroyed their movement and silenced their demand for a voice in decisions affecting their lives. However, their influence did not disappear. The movement helped develop a lasting sense of working-class identity and political unity. Former Luddite Gravener Henson later became an important campaigner for workers' rights. He played a major role in efforts to abolish Britain's anti-union laws, allowing workers to organise formally. Other former Luddite campaigners also contributed to the development of child labour laws. Their history offers an important lesson for the modern world. New technology can create opportunities, improve production and change society, but its benefits and costs must be considered fairly. Workers and ordinary citizens should have a voice in decisions that affect their jobs, communities and future. As AI continues to grow, the central question is not simply whether people should accept or reject technology. It is whether technological progress can protect human dignity, economic security and democratic participation.



Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to write one.
Leave a comment